Nx Plugin for AWS 1.0, AWS Blocks, and Amplify Gen 2 compared on real deployments

A developer tested all three AWS application scaffolding tools — Nx Plugin for AWS 1.0, AWS Blocks (preview), and Amplify Gen 2 — by deploying the same file portal scope on each and then deleting the stacks. All three deployed successfully, but meaningful differences only emerged after deletion, including log groups and KMS keys that persisted beyond stack removal. Amplify Gen 2 creates no perimeter resources by default, AWS Blocks replaces Amazon Cognito with a custom DynamoDB-based auth system, while Nx Plugin for AWS adds WAF web ACLs, Cognito with MFA, and four KMS keys — each contributing to fixed monthly costs even at zero requests. The underlying FSx for ONTAP S3 Access Point data path remained identical and untouched across all three tools, meaning switching scaffolding does not require rebuilding the storage layer. The author concludes that tool choice is reversible, but teams should account for what survives a stack deletion before committing to any option.
This is an AI-generated summary. ShortSingh links to the original source for the complete article.

Discussion (0)
Log in to join the discussion and vote.
Log in