SShortSingh.
Back to feed

Developer finds 5 false claims in own spec; a single tag byte broke a key encoding rule

0
·25 views

A software developer audited 18 formal claims in their own project specification using an automated checker that resolves terms against actual definitions. Of the 18 claims, 9 were valid, 5 were invalid, and 4 returned an unknown result. The most concrete failure involved the encoder being labeled a homomorphism, a mathematically strong claim that a single prepended tag byte renders false for every input. Other errors included conflating related but non-interchangeable graph concepts like DAGs, covering relations, and transitive closures, as well as a direct contradiction between lens round-trip laws and a statement 130 lines away in the same document. The developer argues that retaining 'unknown' as a distinct result category is critical, since collapsing it into 'invalid' would misrepresent assumptions as verified facts.

Read the full story at DEV Community

This is an AI-generated summary. ShortSingh links to the original source for the complete article.

Discussion (0)

Log in to join the discussion and vote.

Log in

Related stories

0
ProgrammingHacker News ·

PharmA2A: Open Protocol Aims to Automate Pharmacy-to-Supplier Orders

A French pharmacist has released PharmA2A, an open source protocol built on the A2A standard to automate orders between pharmacies and their suppliers. The developer says they currently place orders with more than a hundred suppliers by phone, email, or web forms, which motivated the project. The protocol has been publicly available on GitHub since 12 November. The project was shared on Hacker News, where the author asked whether others are using A2A in real-world applications.

0
ProgrammingHacker News ·

IceWM: Lightweight Window Manager Resurfaces on Hacker News

A link to the IceWM project website was shared on Hacker News, drawing a small amount of attention from readers. The post received 10 points and one comment at the time of recording. The source material provides no details about recent releases, features, or announcements from the project. IceWM is a lightweight window manager for the X Window System, but the submission itself offers no further specifics.

0
ProgrammingDEV Community ·

IBM Patches webMethods Integration Server Flaw Allowing 2FA Backup Code Authentication Bypass

IBM disclosed CVE-2026-118904, affecting webMethods Integration Server 12.1, on November 3, 2026. The flaw stems from improper validation of backup codes used in two-factor authentication, allowing an already-authenticated remote attacker to bypass security restrictions. IBM rates it 8.1 on the CVSS scale, with high confidentiality and integrity impact, and recommends applying IS_12.1_Core_Fix1 or later via webMethods Update Manager. The vendor's bulletin does not describe the precise validation error or report any public exploitation. Security analysts advise reviewing logs for suspicious successful access and backup-code use, and verifying that recovery codes are properly rejected after patching.

0
ProgrammingDEV Community ·

How the .NET compiler wires up ModuleInitializer methods, read from decompiled IL

A method marked with ModuleInitializer runs before any other code in an assembly, yet the runtime does not invoke the attribute directly. Decompiling the assembly reveals a static constructor on the reserved module pseudo-type that calls the initializer on the program's behalf. The initializer must be static, parameterless, void, non-generic, and accessible to the module, or the compiler rejects it. The article uses a simple example that sets a readiness flag to show the generated constructor and its IL metadata. It also explains how the free Glass.NET decompiler maps this synthesized code back to the original attributed methods using static analysis alone.