Control experiment exposes flaw in AI security reviewer benchmark
A developer's earlier test showed a security agent catching all ten reverted CVE fix commits, but a reader argued it might simply flag removed code guards. To check, the author ran the same agent on ten non-security control commits with comparable diff sizes. The controls were imperfectly matched, with several drawn from different years and some consisting mostly of documentation changes. The agent produced no comments on seven controls, commented on three, and all three of those comments were judged noise. The author also disclosed that one case required a third attempt after provider timeouts, rather than presenting the runs as perfectly clean.
This is an AI-generated summary. ShortSingh links to the original source for the complete article.
Discussion (0)
Log in to join the discussion and vote.
Log in